Thursday, November 11, 2010

1990 Topps Baseball Coins -- 4 Packs and Review --

Hi again everyone,

I'm back! Today, I'll be reviewing 1990 Topps Baseball Coins and the four packs of it I opened yesterday.

Coins received: 12/60

AL coins received: 6 (American League players, whose coins are gold-rimmed, constitute coins 1-31 in the set. The six AL coins I received include the red-rimmed Kirby Puckett coin.  Coins received, listed in order of coin no., are as follows: Kirby Puckett, Jerry Browne, Tom Candiotti, Don Mattingly, Ruben Sierra, and Alan Trammell.)

NL coins received: 6 (National League players, whose coins are silver-rimmed, constitute coins 32-60 in the set. Coins received, listed in order of coin no., are as follows: Craig Biggio, Will Clark, Sid Fernandez, Dwight Smith, Lonnie Smith, and Tim Wallach.)

Red-rimmed coins received: 1 (Kirby Puckett)

RATINGS

Design: 4/5

From what I can tell, there are three subsets within 1990 Topps Baseball Coins: gold-rimmed, silver-rimmed, and red-rimmed coins. The design basically consists of a player's headshot against an artificially-generated, stylized infield. Each coin also features the names of the player and team on the front and the player's vital stats on the reverse.

Innovation: 4/5

The baseball coins "minted" by Topps from 1987-1990 are a play on the ones it produced in the '60s and '70s. The idea of commemorating sports figures on metal coins is obviously very unique and distinct, yet for the most part, the coins remain undesirable because of their impracticality. Innovation: 4; Collectibility: 1.

Bang for the buck: 3/5

For this product, the rating for this category is especially arbitrary; it essentially boils down to how you feel about the product as a whole. Boxes can be had for a few bucks on eBay, like here and here. So, the cost really isn't an issue; however, because you only get three coins in each pack, and the coins themselves are no more aesthetically or qualitatively attractive than standard 2.5 x 3.5 trading cards, I give this product a 3/5 for "bang for the buck."

Overall: 3/5

The fact that Topps ceased development and production of its "Baseball Coins" after 1990 is demonstrative of the coins' lack of collectibility and inability to enmesh with the trading card industry and its consumers. I enjoyed breaking the few packs that I did, but I wouldn't be too enthused about opening any or many more.

Coin images can be found below, on eBay and checkoutmycards.com, and elsewhere on the internet. If you are interested in seeing the obverse or reverse of a specific coin, I'd be happy to scan and upload it for you if I haven't done so already; just leave a comment. As always, thanks for reading and check back soon!




Sunday, September 12, 2010

Executive Trading Cards' 2009 Politicians Trading Cards Series 1/2 -- Box and Product Review --

Hey everybody,

This is the Cardboard Critic, and today I'll be reviewing a box of 2009 Politicians Trading Cards Series 1/2 so kindly provided to me by Executive Trading Cards. This is my first box break and review as "The Cardboard Critic", so I hope you'll send any suggestions or recommendations my way if you have them. I have also posted a less-comprehensive review on YouTube (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=REfehhwweME).  Without further ado, here is my review:

Cards received: 167/291

Judicial Branch cards received: 2/5 (Associate Justices Anthony M. Kennedy and John Paul Stevens)

Executive Branch cards received: 9/12 (Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, Secretary of Defense Robert Gates, Secretary of the Interior Ken Salazar, Secretary of Transportation Ray LaHood, Secretary of Education Arne Duncan, Secretary of Homeland Security Janet Napolitano, (2) Administrator of the EPA Lisa Jackson, U.S. Trade Representative Ron Kirk, and White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel)

White House cards received: 3/4 (Bo, Air Force One, and Marine One)

Short-printed cards received: 3/8 (Representative Nancy Pelosi, Senator Ted Kennedy, and Secretary Hillary Clinton)


RATINGS

Design: 4/5

The base card design is similar to American paper currency and provides for a very collectible base set. Simple, yet distinguished.

Innovation: 5/5

To my knowledge, this is the only product ever released that focuses exclusively on politics and political figures. It is innovative and unique in more ways than one and has the potential to revolutionize the historical/political realm of trading cards.

Bang for the buck: 3/5

If you choose to, you can sell your short-printed cards back to Executive. Therefore, you are guaranteed to be able to make at least a little bit back on your investment. However, without any truly outstanding inserts, this is a solid low-end product that carries the price tag of a high-end one.

Overall: 4/5

I voiced my only concerns (lack of interesting inserts, card size, price) above and in my YouTube video. Overall, though, I'm a fan of this product and am eagerly awaiting the release of more like it by Executive Trading Cards.

Card images can be found at executivetradingcards.com and elsewhere on the internet. If you are interested in seeing the obverse or reverse of a specific card, I'd be happy to scan it if for you; just leave a comment. Thanks for reading and check back soon!